riley rock index

music’s metaportal: critical clicks

Obituaries 2022

Naomi Judd 1946-2022
Ian McDonald, King Crimson 1946-2022
Taylor Hawkins, Foo Fighters 1972-2022
Bobby Rydell 1940-2022

 

Ronnie Spector

excerpt from Girl Group section of
Fever: How Rock Transforms Gender, by Tim Riley (2003)

…That Spector shaped his empire by singing metaphorically through women is only the first level of irony at work in his career. When he found his dream voice in Ronnie Spector, he immediately went about building a sound around her. (The second level of irony would be that the Ronettes sought out Spector, not the other way around.) After months of merciless rehearsing, the Ronettes finally debuted with “Be My Baby” (another Spector, Barry, and Greenwich credit) in August 1963. But the record wasn’t a pop debut so much as an otherworldly visitation of sexual rapture—hyperbole cheats this music. “Be My Baby” is a pillar of rock excitement, as penetrating and ominous a moment in music as anything by Presley, the Beatles, Springsteen, the Clash, or Prince. This is sexual delight woven so clearly, so gapingly, that it became a symbol for the entire girl-group experience, answering in three minutes of eternal bliss what Presley had been begging to hear since 1955.

The defining beat, held aloft at the opening like a rhythmic magnet pulling the rest of the song along behind, is spacious and beatific—it maps out a cosmic space, and it’s one of the few imperious statements of rhythm alone (boom!… boom-boom BLAM!) in rock that cannot be copied without referencing the original (it rivals as strong a contender as the Bo Diddley beat, used by everybody). But although the beat alone is vast, suggesting realms of feeling for the song to explore, what the rhythm is holding back is what gives it its power. It’s the pauses between beats that give it its candid flirtatiousness, and when Ronnie Spector’s voice unfurls in the opening verse, its promise is fulfilled. Such a voice deserves to be ushered in by a beat that holds the essence of rock’s cocky assurance—which was suddenly trumpeting a woman’s desire just as confidently as any man ever had. Richard Goldstein once called “Be My Baby” “the baby boomers’ Liebestod,” but it also serves as feminism’s wake-up call, an early vision of parity between the sexes. After all, if women could suddenly define their own sexual sensibilities for themselves in rock, where else could they then define it?

That Ronnie Spector manages to turn this beat into her platform, and render the opulent backdrop into mere setting, is at least half of the record’s outlandish charm. It’s impossible to hear what this record does with the familiar I–vi–IV–V doo-wop progression without linking it up to the dreams and ingenuity of its generation. “Be My Baby” is the sound of the fifties graduating into the sixties, as romance and sexual energy flower into larger romantic metaphors: this is a new kind of pop love which extends beyond couples to an entire generation, beyond romance to agape, beyond pitching woo to making a larger promise to an audience—the kind of promise that could suggest the Beatles and everything that followed. It’s a love song addressed to all of rock ’n’ roll, the music’s short history thus far and the worlds it would yet conquer, the teenagers who loved it then and the middle-aged boomers they would become.

With less of a beat the lyric to “Be My Baby” would be one extended cliché. But the love it suggests outstrips teen romance of even the most fantastical kind. In part the love story is about Phil Spector’s awe and reverence for Ronnie’s half-breed voice, that huge, booming contralto that sprang like a geyser from her lithe, beehived frame. She didn’t create excitement by singing higher and higher, as do most singers; she built tension by swerving between her thick, sultry vibrato and her coy, playful pauses. The final “Whoa-oh-oh-oh_____”s at the end of each verse aren’t so much climactic as they are cathartic—an exhalation of carnal triumph.

“Be My Baby” has layers of meaning to match its feelings. It’s about Spector’s high-flying notions that his Wall of Sound could conquer the world, dominate the industry, and turn a reverence for women into a heady pop theme. That these passions were more than justified by the music is only part of his genius. That this nerdy dial-spinner’s reverence for female power made his sound at once girlish and manly only hints at its poetry.

More on Spector >>   more on Fever >>

OBITUARIES 2021-2022

Guardian pop/rock obituaries

Barry Tuckwell

Andy Gill

Neil Innes

Ellis Marsalis

Neil Peart

David Roback

Kenny Rogers

McCoy Tyner

Adam Schlesinger

Peter Serkin

Joseph Shabalala

Ginger Baker

Paul Barrere

Dave Bartholomew

David Berman

Hal Blaine

Asa Brebner

Dr. John

Roky Erickson

João Gilberto

Bonnie Guitar

Neil Innes

Mariss Jansons

Jimmy Johnson

Daniel Johnston

Dave Laing

Roy Loney

Ric Ocasek

Art Neville

Leon Redbone

Ranking Roger

Sara Romweber

Jack Scott

Kim Shattuck

Sleepy LaBeef

Peter Tork

Nick Tosches

Scott Walker

Beverly Watkins

Allee Willis

Reggie Young

BEATLES

BeatlesArchive.net

Beatles Bible

TheBeatles.com

Beatlefan Magazine

Beatlelinks.net

BeatlesTube.net

Reddit:Beatles

Top 100 Beatles Sites

Pinterest Album

Internet Beatles Album

Daily Beatle

MUSIC SITES

All Songs Considered

Alternate Music Press

Anti-Music

Andpop

ArtsJournal

Aquarium Drunkard

AV Club

Bluegrass Situation

Contact Music

Crawdaddy

Creem

Cuepoint

Dazed: Music

Digital Music News

Drowned in Sound

Fast’n’Bulbous

Glide

Glorious Noise

Hits Daily Double

Hollywood Life

ilxor

Idolator

Kerrang!

largehearted boy

McSweeney’s

music think tank

NPR Song of the Day

Oxford American

Paris Atlantic

Perfect Sound Forever

Popmatters

Pitchfork

Arts & Letters Daily

The Quietus

Reverb Nation

Salon

Slate

stereogum

TMZ Music

Wired

REFERENCE

Albums of the Year

All Music Guide

Answers.com

Ask.com

Beaucoups Music

Columbia Encyclopedia

Columbia University Library

DeadRockStarsClub

Discogs

Free Dictionary

Free Library

Historical Text Arch

HitSearch

Headline Spot

Indiana University

Infoplease Music

Int’l Assoc Pop Music

Library Spot Music

Library Thing Music

MusicBrainz

Music Genres List

MusicMoz

New Releases Now

Oxford Music Online

RefDesk

Reverb Ip

Rock Music List

This Day in Music

TuneFind

YOUTUBE

Music

ABC’s In Concert

American Bandstand

American Idol

Beacon Theatre

Bonnaroo Festival

Hollywood A Go Go

Fillmore East

Fillmore West

Live From Abbey Road

Lollapalooza

Monkees

Monterey Pop

Top of the Pops

Old Grey Whistle Test

Playboy After Dark

Royal Albert Hall

Soundstage

Soul Train

Star Search

Ed Sullivan

Unplugged

Woodstock 1969

Woodstock 1994

Woodstock 1999

MUSIC BIZ

AllRecordLabels.com

Americana Association

Billboard.biz

Blues Foundation

BMI

CIMS Music

Conferences, Events

Country Music Hall of Fame

Experience Music Project

Fest300

Grammy

Holler If Ya Hear Me

Hypebot

National Recording Registry

Plug Awards

RIAA News

R&R Hall of Fame

Songwriters Hall of Fame

SXSW

Ticketmaster

Variety

NEWSLETTERS

AllMusic

BlendedBeats

Critical Conditions by Wayne Robins

Louder (NYT)

MusicxTechxFuture

Music Journo Insider

NPR Music

Noisey

OKPlayer

Platform & Stream

Robert Christgau

Redef

Rocksbackpages

That Eric Alper

RILEY ONLINE

Emerson College

Facebook RRI

JFS Speakers Agency

LinkedIn

Blog Riley (2003-18)

Listening Guides

Riley Bibliography

Huffington Post

NPR Riley (WBUR)

Beatles Posts

Dylan Posts

Springsteen Posts

OTHER CRITICS

Robert Christgau

Alan Clayson

Charles Cross

Erik Davis

Anthony DeCurtis

Phil Dellio

Jon Dolan

Chuck Eddy

J. Lester Feder

Sasha Frere-Jones

Simon Frith

Nelson George

Ted Gioia

Sid Griffin

Jason Gross

Jimmy Guterman 1963-2016

David Hajdu

Will Hermes

Jessica Hopper

Tom Hull

Frank Kogan

Allan Kozinn

Steve Knopper

John Leland

Hugo Lindgren

Jim Macnie

Greil Marcus

Michaelangleo Matos

Richard Meltzer

David Menconi

Evelyn McDonnell

Sia Michel

Milo Miles

Joyce Millman

Tom Moon

John Pareles

Ann Powers

Amanda Petrusich

Simon Reynolds

Wayne Robins

Leland Rucker

Chris Salewicz

Kalefa Sanneh

John Sellers

Rob Sheffield

Caroline Sullivan

Kate Sullivan

Jann Uhelszki

Ritchie Unterberger

Elizabeth Vincentelli

Ed Ward

Carl Wilson

Douglas Wolk